Skip to main content

The Research Study



Infinitely Obscure Lives: 


Invisibility of Women at a U.S. Historic Site


 “For all the dinners are cooked; the plates and cups washed; the children sent to school and gone out into the world.  Nothing remains of it all. All has vanished. No biography or history has a word to say about it. And the novels, without meaning to, inevitably lie.
All these infinitely obscure lives remain to be recorded.”
--A Room of One’s Own, Virginia Woolf

Purpose

The purpose of this qualitative study is to create a “disorienting dilemma” (Mezirow & Associates, 1990) which will help students re-examine and critically question their own assumptions about the roles of women and other marginalized groups in the American Old West. 

The Site

Fort Smith National Historic Site


  • Part of the US National Park Service
  • Located in Fort Smith, Arkansas along the Oklahoma border in Northwest Arkansas. 
  • Designated a National Historic Landmark in 1960 and opened as a historic site in 1961
  • Site of a U.S. fort established in 1817
    • First Fort 1817-2824
    • Second Fort 1838-1871
    • Stop along the Trail of Tears (1831-1847)
    • Seat of the Federal US Court for Western Arkansas and Indian Territory (1872-1896)

Questions Guiding the Study

Questions guiding the study are: 
  • What role does naming play in the Historic Site exhibits?
  •  Which women are named? Which women remain unnamed? 
  • How are African American and Native American males portrayed? How are those portrayals different than those of women of any race or ethnicity? 
  • How effective is the "feminist" hack tool in guiding critical thinking and responses to the historic site displays?

The Participants

Group I

  • 9 students visited the historic site (Ages 20-58)
  • 5 students completed the reflections
  • Only 3 students actually posted to the Facebook Page
  • Demographics:
    • 1 male, 8 females
    • Asian 1
    • Caucasian 6
    • African-American 1
    • Hispanic 1

Group II


  • 15 students visited the historic site (Ages 19-45)
  • 10 students completed the reflections
  • Demographics:
    • 4 males, 11 females
    • Asian 1
    • Caucasian 12
    • Hispanic 2

The Instrument


Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

DR, Female, Age 24

Exhibit: Lady Desperado  One of the pieces that stood out to me the most was the section about Belle Starr. She is the only female with her own section in the museum compared to the numerous displays dedicated to men. I noticed that in this particular section her physical appearance is used to describe her, and she is referred to as “flamboyant” and compared to Cleopatra. Out of all of the plaques with men on them none of them described what they looked like, dressed like, or how they drew attention to themselves like hers did. They were remarked on for their accomplishments or their wrong doings, but she is noted for how she looked.  Exhibit Detail: Photo of Belle Starr Another point concerning the Belle Starr section is that any time she is mentioned so are the men in her life. This particular picture shows her picture with a short description underneath that talks about her brother and her father. The museum uses her pictures and titles the boards with h...
Post a Comment
Read more

K.K., Male, Age 24

Exhibit: Belle Starr--Bandit Queen After viewing this photo, I realized that women maybe weren’t as incarcerated as commonly as men were. The caption states that the only time she went to jail was for one occasion of horse theft. I’m thinking that maybe people in that time didn’t see women criminals as serious threats to society as commonly as men were. Now that I think more about it, that’s probably a major advantage if you’re going to be known as a “Bandit Queen.” Exhibit: The Workings of the Court The thing that stuck out to me in this picture is that it was not ever often in that time for a woman to be in a major position of power. It seems like you would always see women in supportive roles rather than leadership roles. All throughout this exhibit we see several pictures of noteworthy men but not a lot of women. It is inspiring to me as I think about how far we have come today. Exhibit: The Gallows This correlates with the first picture pretty well. Hang...
Post a Comment
Read more

DE, Female, Age 24

Exhibit Detail: Members of the U.S. Marshal's staff ca 1900 The first picture I am going to talk about it is called “Women Behind Bar” the picture is suppose to show a women who was arrested and was in a jail cell but you can just barely she the women because there is a group of men standing right in front of the building that cover her up. Some of the picture would talk about what the guy did to be jailed but with this particular woman we have no back-story. Also the descriptions of the picture say “note” like it is giving up extra information about a picture of the men but this picture was actual about the women who were arrested.   Exhibit: Belle Starr--Bandit Queen This next picture is about a Famous women named Belle Starr, It is talking about all she had accomplished and important people in her life, her Son was photographed and named they even talk a little about him. Then there is a picture of Belle Starr with her friends and the friends...
Post a Comment
Read more